Why being able to improvise doesn't necessarily mean we should do it all the time.
By Anja Kotsch | Anja Kotsch Yoga & Breathwork
Inspired by a lunch talk with Amèlia Valls, founder and teacher at Nydum Yoga School, Spain.
How much preparation does a yoga teacher really need?
When I started teaching yoga, I prepared everything.
And I mean everything.
I planned my classes almost minute by minute. I wrote down the sequences, thought about the transitions, and practised the entire class myself. Sometimes several times, just to make sure everything would work.
I wanted to be well prepared. I wanted the timing to be right. And, of course, I wanted to do a good job.
Over time, my approach changed.
I went through phases where preparing classes felt quite challenging. I wanted to create something interesting, avoid repeating the same sequences, and still make sure the class had a clear structure.
Today, I feel much more comfortable with my preparation.
I have built a collection of smaller sequences that I can combine and exchange depending on what I want to teach. Some focus on balance, others on strength, mobility or a particular posture.
I still prepare every class.
I think about how I want to start, how the different parts fit together, and how I want to finish. Sometimes I include a particular breathing technique or meditation. Sometimes I choose a theme from the Yoga Sutras or something related to the moon cycle.
And sometimes there's no specific philosophical theme at all.
That's one of the things I really enjoy about teaching yoga: the creativity.
But then there are the students.
And they don't always follow the plan.
When the class takes a different direction
You can prepare a beautiful sequence, practise it yourself, and feel confident about how everything fits together.
Then you teach it.
And suddenly, a posture takes much longer than expected. Some students struggle with the balance. Others need more time to understand the movement.
Or you notice that the energy in the room is completely different from what you anticipated.
That's when improvisation becomes important.
Sometimes I add a small sequence between two planned parts of the class. Sometimes I adjust the pace or introduce another movement to prepare students for a more challenging posture.
I like having that flexibility.
But during a recent lunch with my former yoga teacher, Amèlia Valls from Nydum Yoga School, we discussed something that made me look at improvisation differently.
We're not there to make everything easy
One of Amèlia's points was that our job as yoga teachers isn't to remove every challenge from the practice.
We're there to guide people, help them move and give them opportunities to improve.
And improvement often involves doing something that feels difficult at first.
That really resonated with me.
When I see students struggling with a posture, my first instinct can be to change something. To make it a little easier, add another preparation or choose a different movement.
But is that always necessary?
Amèlia suggested looking at how many people are actually struggling.
If one or two students find a posture challenging, that doesn't automatically mean the whole sequence needs to change.
If half the class is struggling, or almost everyone, that's a different situation.
Then it might be worth reconsidering the exercise, the preparation or the way the movement was explained.
I found this distinction really helpful.
Of course, struggling with a challenging balance is different from experiencing pain or moving in a way that creates an unnecessary risk. Those situations need a different response, regardless of how many students are affected.
And individual students may need modifications even when the rest of the group is doing fine.
But I do think there's a difference between supporting someone through a challenge and immediately removing the challenge altogether.
That's something I want to pay more attention to.
The hidden problem with improvisation
There was another point Amèlia made that stayed with me even more.
She said that being able to improvise is a great skill.
It means you have experience, a good repertoire of exercises and the confidence to adapt when necessary.
But there's a downside.
When you're constantly thinking about what to do next, you're not fully present with your students.
That really hit me.
Because I recognised exactly what she meant.
When I improvise, I'm sometimes already thinking about the next posture while teaching the current one.
Does this sequence still make sense? Should I add another movement? How much time do I have left? What's the best transition?
And while I'm busy answering those questions in my head, part of my attention is no longer with the people in front of me.
I'm not observing them as closely. I'm less aware of the atmosphere in the room. And perhaps I'm not communicating with the same clarity or enthusiasm either.
The students might simply be watching me thinking.
Not exactly what I want them to experience.
Preparation creates space for presence
I've always thought of preparation as something that helps me deliver a well-structured class.
Now I'm starting to see another benefit.
Good preparation creates mental space.
When I know where the class is going, I don't have to spend so much time thinking about what comes next.
I can pay more attention to the people in the room.
How are they moving? How are they responding to the sequence? Do they need more time, a different explanation or a moment to pause?
Instead of constantly planning the next step, I can focus on teaching the one we're doing.
And that doesn't mean following a rigid script.
It means having enough structure to be flexible without constantly having to invent the class while teaching it.
This is also where my collection of smaller sequences becomes useful.
If I know several ways to move from one posture to another, or have a few alternative sequences ready, I can adjust without having to build everything from scratch in my head.
Perhaps the real skill isn't improvising more.
It's making improvisation feel natural because the preparation is already there.
Finding my own balance as a teacher
I'm still developing my approach to teaching.
And I quite like that.
My first classes were carefully planned and rehearsed. Then came a period of experimenting, changing things and figuring out how much preparation I actually needed.
Now I feel I'm finding a better balance between structure and flexibility.
But the conversation with Amèlia reminded me that there's another aspect I hadn't considered enough: the relationship between improvisation and presence.
I don't want to be so focused on my plan that I stop responding to the students.
But I also don't want to spend the entire class thinking about the next sequence.
I want to challenge people without overwhelming them. Adapt when necessary without changing everything at the first sign of difficulty. And create classes that have a clear intention while still leaving room for the unexpected.
That's probably one of the things I enjoy most about teaching yoga.
There's always something to learn.
And sometimes a conversation over lunch gives you more to think about than another hour of practising postures.

